The New Yorker Hotel, New York City, United States

Search for:
The New Yorker Hotel Hotel Reviews - Travel Library
Home > Hotels > United States > New York > New York City > The New Yorker Hotel

The New Yorker Hotel New York City

Traveller Reviews

     Rating

2.3/10

Official Contact Details - The New Yorker Hotel

"I had the misfortune of staying in the New Yorker last weekend for 2 nights......"

"The hotel is 75 years old and smells like it has never replaced it's carpets......"

Reviews of the The New Yorker Hotel

3 reviews
Review this Hotel

Rating:

1/10
By far the worst hotel ever stayed in
Submitted by: Grant in Sep 2007
  • Age Group: 41 - 50
  • From: United Kingdom
  • Adventurer
I had the misfortune of staying in the New Yorker last weekend for 2 nights while passing through New York after visiting friends in Kentucky. I paid 520 US dollars for 2 nights room only for myself and my wife.[ I paid 800 dollars for 8 nights in the Hilton at Cinncinati Airport and would recommend it to anyone] Firstly the room was a discrace. very dirty, very small, smelt damp wall paper looked damp, bed felt damp would not have let my dogs sleep in that room. The carpets in the room and in all th corridors were very dirty and also looked damp. The toilet in our room was the smallest I have ever seen. Our stay was a very bad end to an otherwise great Holiday. To top it all I got bitten all over my legs whilst sleeping and was scratching for my intire stay. The New Yorker is a total rip off in the Capital of the rip of cities.
12 out of 12 readers found this review helpful
Was this review helpful? Yes - No

Rating:

2/10
if pics were
Submitted by: Travel Library User in Sep 2007
  • Age Group: 31 - 40
  • From: United Kingdom
  • Family Traveller
The hotel is 75 years old and smells like it has never replaced it's carpets in all those years...but the 30s vintage bathrooms are a treat! Good location so go after it has been renovated
11 out of 11 readers found this review helpful
Was this review helpful? Yes - No

Rating:

4/10
Great location, but...
Submitted by: Dave in Oct 2006
  • Age Group: 26 - 30
  • From: United Kingdom
  • Young Couple
Just got back from my stay at the New Yorker. I will summarize my thoughts in the following bullet points for easy reading: Good Points: > Hotel is in a superb location. Walking distance from most major sites > View from breakfast room is fantastic (floor 39 overlooks financial district & Empire State Building). Breakfast is all-you-can eat and is very nice with friendly service > Food in the hotel restaurant (not the 24hr Tik Tok Diner) is excellent, with friendly service. Recommend the Fillet Mignon! Bad Points: > Hotel is majorly under-equipped for its size. Constant queues at reception / guests waiting around make the whole entrance lobby look like a shambles > The rooms/corridors are in MAJOR need of refurbishment. Wallpaper patches, stained/damaged decor, badly stained carpets all look bad. Apparently refurbishment is underway but I saw no sign of this, and no finish date is apparent. > Hotel sells itself on views. Due to the bizarre shape of the...... Read more
32 out of 32 readers found this review helpful
Was this review helpful? Yes - No

Read 598 additional reviews of the The New Yorker Hotel at TripAdvisor

Want to see more hotels? View all 4 star hotels in New York City

 loading...

Review & Rate the The New Yorker Hotel

Have you stayed at this accommodation? Share your experience by reviewing this property's rooms, location, amenities, and services.

Booking inquiries or messages meant for the staff of this property will NOT be forwarded through this form.
Your First Name: Add your pictures
Date of stay:
Type of traveller:
Age Group:
Your Country:
Your Email: (Won't be published)
Your Rating:
Review Title: (ex: Great Service & Staff!)
Your Review:
(As a reminder,
you can review the price, location, rooms, restaurants, bars, staff, services)
Please confirm you abide by our Terms and Conditions and understand that this form is used to publish your feedback (on this page) about your stay at this property.

NOTE: If you represent the management of this property and would like to respond to a review, please use the management response form.

 loading...

Browse & Compare Accommodation

Explore

Popular Travel Destinations

Recently Reviewed Hotels Around New York City

  • Casablanca Hotel West 43rd Street New York City New York 9/10 4 reviews Hotel Class 4 42 Rooms
  • Affinia Manhattan Hotel 371 7th Ave New York City New York 8/10 5 reviews Hotel Class 0 492 Rooms
  • Millennium Broadway West 44th Street Broadway New York City New York 8/10 7 reviews Hotel Class 4 638 Rooms
  • Hotel 41 at Times Square West 41street New York City New York 8/10 6 reviews Hotel Class 4 47 Rooms
  • The Waldorf Astoria Park Avenue New York City New York 8/10 8 reviews Hotel Class 4 1425 Rooms
  • Hilton Times Square West 42nd Street Manhattan New York City New York 8/10 3 reviews Hotel Class 4 455 Rooms
  • Travel Inn 515 W 42nd St F1 10 New York City New York 8/10 2 reviews Hotel Class 0 160 Rooms
  • Westin New York at Times Square West 43rd Street New York City New York 8/10 4 reviews Hotel Class 4 863 Rooms
  • New York Marriott Marquis Broadway New York City New York 8/10 2 reviews Hotel Class 3 1946 Rooms
  • Sheraton Hotel and Towers 7th Avenue 53rd Street New York City New York 6/10 2 reviews Hotel Class 4 1750 Rooms
  • Edison West 47th Street Downtown New York City New York 6/10 12 reviews Hotel Class 3 900 Rooms
  • Belvedere West 48th Street Manhattan New York City New York 5/10 5 reviews Hotel Class 3 440 Rooms
  • Park Central New York 7th Avenue Manhattan New York City New York 5/10 12 reviews Hotel Class 3 935 Rooms
  • Paramount Hotel West 46th Street Downtown New York City New York 5/10 5 reviews Hotel Class 4 608 Rooms
  • NYC Paramount Hotel West 46th Street New York City New York 1/10 4 reviews Hotel Class 4 328 Rooms