Gurney's Inn Resort & Spa Hotel

, Montauk, United States
Nearby Airports
Review this Hotel
Popular Travel Destinations

Recently Reviewed Hotels Around Montauk

Gurney's Inn Resort & Spa Hotel

, Montauk

Rooms: 109

290 Old Montauk Hwy - Montauk - New York - 11954 - United States | 631/668-2345
183 Traveller

Reviews - Gurney's Inn Resort & Spa Hotel

Dump/Rude Staff
Submitted by: Laurie in 28/02/11
  • Age Group: 4150
  • From: United States
  • Traveller type: Adventurer
This place is like a throw back to the 1950's-Outdated and dumpy. The lobby had stains all over the ceiling tiles. Everthing looked like it needed a good dusting. The outside of the building looks like it's falling apart and they keep throwing paint over it.

The waitstaff for the breakfast buffet were the most unfriendly group of people I have had wait on me in a long time. I could not even get the table cleaned off or a second cup of coffee...I asked three times!! Oh and the place smalls dirty.

One good daughter loved swimming in the indoor pool and the young lefegueard there was very diligent in watching all the children. The views are beautiful. SO if you are going to be on the beach mainly -go for it. I would not go here for an extended stay or book a wedding here until they clean the place up.
Gerneys Inn
Submitted by: A Travel Library User in 11/08/05
  • Age Group: 31 - 40
  • From: United States
  • Traveller type: Young Couple
OH my ! What a mess, do not stay in this dump. They are still riding on their name from 30 some odd years ago. The place is awful! A dump! Not kept at all. The place is filthy, the service is terrible and they are so rude. Yeah they have a spa but it's so old, good luck if you get in the tubs & showers. In short the resturant is horrible, the place is broke. Don't waste your money.

Top Local Tips for Montauk

Overrated. Avoid. You can't even enjoy the beach as one person has to guard the car in case beach patrol comes in. Where do you get the beach passes on Labor Day when everything is closed?? (not at Gurney's Inn for sure!). And the surfers even suck.

Dining Be careful about the 18% service charge and requests for tipping additionally from the staff

great place to eat Cyril's seaside- small local owned seafood bar and restaurant. Ask for the special menu- amazing caribbean spiced seafood. Food was great for a roadside setting with great locals on a summer afternoon! No cards- cash only.


Other names for Gurney's Inn Resort & Spa Hotel

  • gurneys spa
  • gurneys resort montauk
  • gurneys resort
  • gurneys inn resort
  • gurneys inn montauk
  • gurneys hotel montauk
  • gurneys hotel
  • Address: 290 Old Montauk Hwy - Montauk - New York - 11954 - United States
Travel Library Traveller Rating?

See All 183 reviews

"Dump/Rude Staff" - Laurie

"Gerneys Inn" - A Travel Library User

Review this Hotel
Candid Traveller Photos
  •  Loading Image...
  •  Loading Image...
  •  Loading Image...
  •  Loading Image...

Hotels Near Gurney's Inn Resort & Spa Hotel